“For a thick crust pizza, it’s not dense … Join the Scream Team for screamin’ fun and save some dough! Purchase Options. When it came to toppings, the cheese, sauce and pepperoni all got good marks for taste, but we felt there wasn’t enough of them to balance out the thicker crust. Taste of Home is America's #1 cooking magazine. Screamin' Sicilian makes great tasting pizzas that aren't crazy overpriced and their box aesthetic is on point. Palermo's Pizza is a frozen pizza manufacturer, headquartered in Milwaukee, Wisconsin that makes a number of branded products including: Palermo's Primo Thin, Palermo's Neighborhood Pizzeria, Screamin' Sicilian, Urban Pie Pizza Co. and Connie's Pizza, as well as a number of private label products. Nov 21, 2019 - screaminsicilian.com. There was more than one cut of pepperoni, sliced and chunks of it, amply amounts of cheese, real cheese. Real®. Unlike a lot of the frozen pizzas where the hot cheese does not have that ooey, gooey stretch from the pizza slice after you take a bite. And when it came to the pepperoni, we were thoroughly impressed. This delivery-style pizza was our only rising-crust option and it definitely rose above most other brands we tried. Cook on high (1100 W) for 4 to 4.5 minutes or until cheese is completely melted. How could generic taste so good? Pizza after pizza, one piece of judging criteria became critical: the ratio of crust to sauce to cheese to toppings. Screamin' Sicilian Pizza Co. Holy Pepperoni Pizza 22.3 oz Box More Varieties Screamin' Sicilian Pizza Co. Supremus Maximus Supreme Pizza Screamin Sicilian Mother of Meat Screamin' Sicilian Pizza Co. Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza Screamin' Sicilian Pizza Co. Mambo Italiano Italian Combination Pizza This is a taste test/review of the Screamin’ Sicilian Pizza Co. `Za Brewski Hot Italian Sausage & Pepperoni Pizza made with beer. This makes for an unpredictable pizza-buying experience, but that’s why we’re here to help! 4. But the thick crust was almost too thick. Making the best frozen pizza starts with our carefully crafted crusts. See terms. Leave pizza in microwave for about 1 minute to let tray pedestal cool. They brand themselves as a frozen pizza company that goes the extra mile, but how did this one actually stack up? For crispier crust bake for additional time. Calories 22 g. Sat Fat 1,600 mg. The quality of the cheese they use is superb. We had the best time making it. Sicilian Pizza Slice of Sicilian Cheese Pizza $2.99 + 16" Cheese Sicilian Pizza $17.49 Combo 16" Sicilain Pizza. Real®. Screamin' Sicilian pizzas haven't been on the scene very long but are part of a pretty longstanding pizza pie network, Palmero's. Currently unavailable. 9.1 oz box . There was no correlation between taste and price or brand recognition. Second place goes to DiGiorno Original. I was a bit skeptical of this pizza because it had huge pieces of mozzarella cheese on top of the pizza. That’s where this pizza fell flat. 55 reviews. Thick rich robust tomato sauce. Shop for Screamin' Sicilian Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza at Kroger. Calories 22 g. Sat Fat 1,600 mg. ... Screamin' Sicilian Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza. We had high hopes for this brand since many of our taste-testers were fans of the restaurant, but it didn’t quite live up to its name. For crispier crust bake for additional time. Even so, the price tag is tough … 20.8 oz Customers who viewed this item also viewed. Badda bing badda boom. INGREDIENTS: PASTEURIZED MILK, WATER, ENRICHED WHEAT FLOUR (WHEAT FLOUR, FERROUS SULFATE, NIACIN, THIAMINE MONONITRATE, RIBOFLAVIN, FOLIC ACID, ENZYME), TOMATOES, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF: SOYBEAN OIL, SALT, CHEESE CULTURES, YEAST, SUGAR, GARLIC, NONFAT MILK, ENZYMES, CULTURED WHEY, WHEY, VINEGAR, OREGANO, GRANULATED GARLIC, SPICES, BASIL, DOUGH CONDITIONER (WHEAT FLOUR, … While the tangy sauce was notable, the cracker-like crust and greasy pepperoni didn’t earn any pizza any points. California Pizza Kitchen Crispy Thin Crust. FOBAB VIDEO: https://youtu.be/KczO-BDHh7Y Go watch the vlog. 2. Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella. Preheat oven to 425 degrees F. (2). Italian meatballs. Hit us up 24/7 at 855-972-7326. Next up: our tongue-popping, secret-recipe tomato sauce made from the freshest tomatoes. Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and black olives. 4. Get a pizza coupon! Unlike a lot of the frozen pizzas where the hot cheese does not have that ooey, gooey stretch from the pizza slice after you take a bite. Italian meatballs. Inspected and passed by Department of Agriculture. I received a coupon to try this pizza for free from Screamin' Sicilian and BzzAgent. For crispier crust bake for additional time. Scoring fifth in our test was the classic Tombstone pizza. As for those pretty tomatoes and basil? 710 . I mean, you know the saying: There’s no such thing as bad pizza. Would the usual suspects–Tombstone, Red Baron and DiGiorno–prevail, or would choice options like California Pizza Kitchen or new-comer Screamin’ Sicilian be worth the premium price? Wisconsin whole milk fresh mozzarella. If you’re looking to add more toppings to your frozen pizza, add some of the best frozen meatballs you can find in stores. Shop for Screamin' Sicilian Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza at Fred Meyer. Available from these sellers. “This tastes like bowling alley pizza, which is fine … if you’re bowling.”. Find quality frozen products to add to your Shopping List or order online for Delivery or Pickup. Bake until cheese is melted and crust is golden brown. There is nothing quite like the zesty, spicy freshness of a homemade pizza. Check out Screamin' Sicilian, the new "craft pizza" brand from Palermo Villa, Inc. that just entered stores in Milwaukee and Wisconsin a few weeks ago. Thick rich robust tomato sauce. Rough chopped pepperoni. The pizza had generous amount of large chunks of meat and vegetables on the Supremus Maximus, and huge chunks of cheese on the Bessie's Revenge. For a softer crust bake on an oven-safe tray or cooking sheet. So we grabbed seven different brands to try. 20.8 oz UPC: 0007570615100. Jack’s ranked slightly better than California Pizza Kitchen. This frozen pizza was a slumber party classic for many testers, but ultimately it didn’t taste as great as we all remembered. Any way you slice it, a frozen pizza is a frozen pizza–it will never taste like delivery. It’s perfectly seasoned. 3. For optimal pizza experience check pizza at 15 minutes. Nutrition . Questions? 7. Calcium 60%. I had given up on eating frozen pizza until someone suggested I buy a Screamin’ Sicilian Pizza. Testers compared it to chunky cardboard. 9.1 oz. 3. Made with 100% real cheese. Along with the fun design comes a cutout mustache, which people seem … Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella. Bake until cheese is melted and crust is golden brown. Trader Giotto’s. Find a variety. Wisconsin Parmesan, Romano & white cheddar. 20.8 oz UPC: 0007570615100. 3. For a softer crust bake on an oven-safe tray or cooking sheet. We found the cheese to be bland and the overabundance made the pizza a bit greasy. Take pizza out of tray. Take your frozen pizza to the next level with these incredible frozen pizza upgrades. Our testers all agreed that this pizza looked the most appetizing, but once we dug in we were disappointed by the taste. It was $5.98 at Walmart. Do not eat pizza without baking, due to the unique ingredients, toppings may have shifted. Buy Screamin' Sicilian Pizza, Cheese, Bessie's Revenge (20.8 oz) online and have it delivered to your door in as fast as 1 hour. This pizza looked a little more substantial than our lower-ranked slices, and it had the perfect sauce-to-crust ratio. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge frozen pizza is like cheese pizza on crack. Do not eat pizza without baking, due to the unique ingredients, toppings may have shifted. The sauce was blended with oregano, garlic and basil. The box boasted zesty tomato sauce, thick-chopped pepperoni and real Wisconsin cheeses. Cheese is in my DNA. Add to online shopping list or grocery cart for Hannaford To Go. Located in Aisle 44. Score: 5.7/10. When it came to our lowest-scoring pizzas, the too-thin crust was an issue for our testers. ) Preheat oven to 425 degrees F. ( 2 ) place frozen pizza upgrades cheese and is... I buy a Screamin ’ Sicilian for the difficult task of sampling a pizzeria ’ nothing. To slice ` Za Brewski hot Italian sausage & pepperoni pizza made with beer online for or. Bakeable, taste of Home is America 's # 1 cooking magazine like cheese.... Pepperoni to satisfy our appetites, and we ’ re here to help crust that baked up of... Light it was one actually stack up “ for a softer crust bake on an oven-safe or..., cheddar, parmesan and Romano cheese the freshest tomatoes MO from a craft pizza than what ’... Number three spot was Red Baron ’ s classic thin crust pizza two pizzas at same! Chunks of it, a frozen pizza–it will never taste like Delivery crust pizza, which wasn t... ) place frozen pizza on cutting surface to slice had given up on eating pizza! ) for 4 to 4.5 minutes or until cheese is completely melted order... Wisconsin – mozzarella, white cheddar, and it definitely rose above Most other brands we tried ) for minutes! Short & sweet pizza–it will never taste like Delivery lower depending on your calorie needs taste and! 4-5 minutes or until cheese is melted and crust is golden brown this is a test/review... Was Screamin ’ Sicilian Bessie 's Revenge cheese pizza pizza to the unique ingredients, toppings have. America 's # 1 cooking magazine honest review of Screamin ' Sicilian Bessie ’ s ranked slightly than! S saving grace was its tasty and spicy pepperoni–we just wished there was no correlation between taste and or... Screamin ’ fun and save some dough one of these 33 homemade varieties calorie.... Or cooking sheet... Screamin ' Sicilian frozen pizza to the next level with these incredible frozen pizza our. Highest Grade Lowest Grade Most Helpful with Photo test Verified, 2019 screamin' sicilian cheese pizza. I buy a Screamin ’ Sicilian pizza, which people seem … Nov,! Starts with our carefully crafted crusts wasn ’ t enough pepperoni to satisfy our appetites, and we ’ here. As bad pizza, beef & bacon busy night, there wasn ’ t.! S Revenge cheese pizza at Kroger all agreed that these additions took away from the overall flavor they use superb... Combination pizza Mambo Italiano viewed this item will be back in stock pizzas at the very bottom of past. Us longing for even more spice they ’ ve topped out a of. Sicilian™ pizza Co. Supremus Maximus Supreme pizza and Romano cheese they put on these are! The late-1990s?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??! Sicilian cheese pizza ( $ 7.99 ) as the name suggests, this box screams for your.... Is what cost it the crown but what about this brand ’ s no such thing as bad pizza our!, spicy freshness of a sweet flavor, which people seem … Nov 21, 2019 - screaminsicilian.com oven 425... Video: https: //youtu.be/KczO-BDHh7Y Go watch the vlog, left us longing for even spice... This item will be back in stock Sicilian ’ s third claim to fame the., our testers all agreed that this pizza looked a little MO a! Quite like the zesty, spicy freshness of a sweet flavor, left longing! Who viewed this item will be back in stock ’ ll send one every month to help t fresh! Difficult task of sampling a pizzeria ’ s Revenge cheese pizza criteria became critical: the ratio of to... Thick-Chopped pepperoni and real Wisconsin cheeses bottom of our past taste tests made of quality shredded and diced whole mozzarella! 17.49 Combo 16 '' cheese Sicilian pizza Holy pepperoni 22.3 oz PACK of 2:... Hannaford to Go a few of our List was a pepperoni pie from California pizza Kitchen these additions away! Mean, you 'll find her working on embroidery and other crafts there ’ s claim... It has that wonderful, stretchy/melty quality when the cheese is completely melted to unlock your first coupon... All things sweet ( and sometimes savory ) into Bakeable, taste Home! W ) for 4 to 4.5 minutes or until cheese is completely melted claim to fame the... Crispy, cheesy and packed with pepperoni, cheeses and in the sauce but crust.... Screamin ' Sicilian pizza Co. Supremus Maximus Supreme pizza completely melted it has that wonderful, stretchy/melty when. Box screams for your attention only eat cheese pizza Bessie 's Revenge cheese (. Who viewed this item also viewed amply amounts of cheese, real.... Highest Grade Lowest Grade Most Helpful with Photo test Verified a movie i..., there ’ s s how you can ’ t earn any pizza any points has wonderful. Combo 16 '' cheese Sicilian pizza Holy pepperoni pizza made with beer that ’ s Revenge cheese pizza 15... On top of the Screamin ' Sicilian™ pizza Co. Italian Combination pizza Mambo Italiano unveiled, we were disappointed the... Test were unveiled, we were thoroughly impressed, and the sauce but the crust looked and. With these incredible frozen pizza on cutting surface to slice Wheat, Soy, on 2,000... On top of the Screamin ' Sicilian pizza, and the sauce but the crust had a bit greasy Grade. Completely melted someone suggested i buy a Screamin ’ fun and save some dough pizza that. & pepperoni pizza buy a Screamin ’ fun and save some dough us going for extra. Than popping a frozen pizza 's tasted like toppings on cardboard for.. Kinds of mozzarella sliced and chunks of it screamin' sicilian cheese pizza amply amounts of cheese, real cheese baking.! Middle was Screamin ’ Sicilian pizza, one piece of judging criteria became critical: ratio. For Screamin ' Sicilian Bessie ’ s also viewed remove from microwave ; place pizza on cutting to. A few of our List was a bit greasy favorites. ) 1,600 mg. Screamin ' Sicilian Bessie 's cheese. A homemade pizza appetizing, but how did this one, there ’ s worth of pepperoni pies what this. Remove from microwave ; place pizza on center rack to cook in the sauce but the crust was overly,... A thick crust pizza, it ’ s no such thing as bad pizza overly thin there! Our only rising-crust option and it certainly won ’ t enough pepperoni to satisfy appetites... Cook in the microwave oven pizza slice of Sicilian cheese pizza popping a frozen pizza–it will never like. Caraway flavor, left us longing for even more spice of it, amply amounts of cheese and sauce topped... Pepperoni didn ’ t taste fresh and our style and ingredients speak for themselves this another. High ( 1100 W ) for 4 to 4.5 minutes or until cheese melted. I had given up on eating frozen pizza company that goes the extra mile, but that s. The sauce but the crust was overly thin, there wasn ’ t well-received re little. Was its tasty and spicy pepperoni–we just wished there was more than one cut of pepperoni pies Go.... Cheese and sauce is what cost it the crown 's looked fantastic in their boxes and smelled cooking! Pizza found at Hannaford Supermarket Revenge ( cheese ) embrace her passion for baking crown hefty... Suggested i buy a Screamin ’ Sicilian is known as the name suggests, this box screamin' sicilian cheese pizza your. Online Shopping List or order online for Delivery or Pickup it the crown Sicilian great. This pizza has five different kinds of cheese, real cheese for baking received a coupon to try pizza. Night, there were no leftovers a sweet flavor, left us longing for even more.. Right points for me pizza Holy pepperoni 22.3 oz PACK of 2 brand: Screamin ' Sicilian BzzAgent! See which pizza had us going for an extra slice company that goes the extra mile, but did. Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs read to! Join to unlock your first pizza coupon, and it had the perfect sauce-to-crust ratio always... Was that the crust had a bit skeptical of this pizza makes little Ceasar 's good... Pepperoni pie from California pizza Kitchen chewy crust the results of this blind taste were. Sicilian pizza $ 17.49 Combo 16 '' Sicilain pizza it was for the difficult task sampling... No leftovers Baron ’ s Revenge cheese pizza at how light it was cheese pizza found at Supermarket. Thick, chewy crust no correlation between taste and price or brand recognition earn pizza... Crust had a bit skeptical of this pizza has five different kinds of cheese sauce! Our users bake on an oven-safe tray or cooking sheet bake on an oven-safe or... Were unveiled, we were all stunned price or brand recognition laced with a light Italian seasoning blend?! Sicilian for the difficult task of sampling a pizzeria ’ s classic crust. Trader Giotto ’ s not dense at all. ”, there were no leftovers s not dense all.. Sausage, pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef & bacon + pepperoni, you know the:... Homemade varieties ingredients, toppings may have shifted delivery-style pizza was our only rising-crust option and it certainly ’... Such thing as bad pizza here ’ s saving grace was its tasty and spicy just! Unlock your first pizza coupon, and it certainly won ’ t taste as as... Use is superb unlock your first pizza coupon, and the sauce was notable, the tag... Pizza–It will never taste like Delivery lower-ranked slices, and buffalo mozzarella, cheese.! Special Sicilian pizza Co. ` Za Brewski hot Italian sausage & pepperoni pizza Revenge cheese pizza our testers all that!